“If we weren’t successful in sport you wouldn’t have even heard of us,” he says. “Many, many countries around the world which have a far bigger population than us … also export sheep and butter.”
“When you go through immigration at Heathrow or JFK or LA, or whatever, they say, ‘Where you from?’ You just put your passport down and say, ‘New Zealand mate, that’s where the All Blacks are from.’
“There’s a sense of pride that you have with that and that resonates itself throughout the country. Wearing the pride of the nation through the sport on your sleeve because we’re not a superpower, granted we have great rivers and mountains, but our sport is our passion and our success.”
The All Blacks have won the last two World Cups. No team has won three titles in succession — but few countries are as devoted to the sport or as talented as New Zealand.
“You’re wanting to do the history proud, the public proud and you make sure you do everything you possibly can for that little country down at the bottom of the world.”
But this is not just about rugby — this is about how that “little country down at the bottom of the world,” that Carter refers to, has managed to compete against the bigger nations so successfully across a range of sports.
‘Punch above our weight’
For a country with a population under five million, its prowess on the sporting stage has always appeared to be disproportionate.
Olympic champions in rowing, sailing, canoeing, home of the America’s Cup-winning Team New Zealand, and a force in track cycling, New Zealand’s success in sports is not an accident but a byproduct of its society.
Bruce, who has been researching the meaning of the Rugby World Cup to New Zealanders, believes the country’s relationship with Britain, its geographical location and early success in sport have all contributed to its modern-day success.
“I think the question really comes down to who we think we are as New Zealanders,” Bruce told CNN.
“We are pretty small, there’s not a lot of us and we kind of punch above our weight as we like to say. I think that’s partly because we’ve been successful in sport and it’s one of the few places where we’ve been able to be visible on the international stage.
“I do think the size of the country and the fact we’re a relatively new nation, we were never really locked into any set ideas about who we would be or who we were. That gave a kind of freedom to develop a sense of identity.
“Also, we’re a long way from everywhere. Access to resources was really expensive and so there’s a set of values I think we take for granted which are actually quite advantageous in sport. So things like adaptability, resourcefulness, there’s a really strong sense of egalitarianism.”
Bruce cites New Zealand’s successful 1905 rugby tour to Britain where the All Blacks won 34 of its 35 games as the moment where the mindset within the country began to shift.
That tour, and Britain’s decision to grant New Zealand “Dominion Status” two years later, were both pivotal in convincing New Zealanders of their place in the world, Bruce says.
“Success started early,” Bruce said. “People talk about the 1905 rugby tour to Britain and that was a really successful tour. That kind of cemented rugby’s place as maybe one of those areas of cultural highs that we should give attention to.
“One of the things we often find as researchers is that there’s often a connection between what becomes important and whatever cultural issues or questions we’re asking ourselves at the time.
“Around that time of Dominion, there was a sense of what does it mean to be a New Zealander? Are we just little Englanders? How do we mark ourselves out as different? So, what kind of repeatedly became a way we could show we were a unique people?
“Sports, historically and for a long time, has been one of those places where our sports people, both men and women, have been at the top of the world consistently. We have really built a sense of who we are around sport.”
The success New Zealand has enjoyed in sport has spawned a culture that encourages it to be played as far and widely as possible.
Specialization, choosing just one sport to focus on, is generally discouraged and schools offer a number of activities for students.
“The dangers of early specialization have been found out. There have been obviously certain cases where the early specializers have been successful and I think there could be a little bit of survivorship by it in that you don’t see all the cases that haven’t been successful from that paradigm.
“New Zealand has a very small population relatively speaking so we can’t get away with those black-and-white dichotomy approaches where we try and force the athletes to conform to this particular system of training or specialization. We have to be a little more individualistic in the approach.”
Weekends are also crucial in nurturing a love of sport, according to Richard Pithey, head of New Zealand Cricket’s national youth coaching program.
He says that most children join a club and play at least one summer and one winter sport.
“Saturday sport is a culture in New Zealand,” Pithy told CNN.
“Those that live in small or medium-sized rural towns in particular often play multiple sports. Early specialization is discouraged to the extent that Sport New Zealand have a website ‘balance is better,’ which promotes this philosophy.
“Parents obviously play a very important role in this, as most have been brought up playing sports so they naturally encourage their kids to play as well.
“Most youth sport is coached by parents so they are usually involved one way or another. Informal play in the backyard or school playground, e.g. backyard cricket is also very common and the benefits of this shouldn’t be underestimated.
“Most sports have introductory programs which are age and stage appropriate to ensure the kids’ experiences are fun and enjoyable. Junior coaches are encouraged to create an environment where kids enjoy their experiences, learn new skills through fun games or activities and come back the following season.”
“You’re encouraged to get into it and try a few sports not just one,” Taylor said. “I played hockey and cricket was my main one but you played rugby, touch, netball, basketball, all those sports are encouraged to get in there and my kids are no different. They try and get out there and explore and have a bit of fun as well.
“Obviously, playing sport all year round, they all complement each other very well and I guess the fitness as well, that component of it.”
‘Inbuilt determination born of being small’
New Zealand’s success has not gone unnoticed, particularly within the governmental and diplomatic sphere, according to the country’s minister for sport Grant Robertson.
Robertson, an avid cricket fan and a one-time ball boy during the British and Irish Lions’ visit to Dunedin in 1983, says he can barely hold a meeting without someone wanting to talk to him about the All Blacks or New Zealand’s sporting achievements.
While the All Blacks have become a global brand, Robertson, who is also the country’s finance minister, says the performances of the men’s cricket team has opened up a market in India such has been the admiration for the way the Black Caps play the game.
He believes the value placed on sport within New Zealand culture has enabled it to thrive on the very biggest of stages.
“There is something in the New Zealand psyche that really values sport,” Robertson told CNN. “The other element is that we’ve chosen our sports quite well in rugby, netball, cricket, they are sports that come from our history, where we are, they’re not as widely played as say, football and maybe that has helped us a bit.
“In other sports like rowing, yachting, cycling, we have had success in those areas where we are up against big countries with big programs.
“New Zealanders do have some inbuilt determination born of being small, if you’re the youngest kid in the family or the smallest kid in the classroom, you will fight twice as hard to get some because you kind of know that you need a sense of determination to get past that …
“Some people call it being the underdog but it is that spirit of determination born of being a small country in inverted commas at the bottom of the world.”
Robertson, who hopes to be able to witness another All Blacks World Cup triumph in Japan on November 2, is also aware how vital success can be in inspiring future generations to take up sport.
He cites the excitement generated by the exploits of the country’s netball stars as evidence of the effect success can have on the population
“We all need heroes and these heroes are created through these pinnacle events,” Robertson added.
“We know that from netball, straight out the back of the World Cup, they went and did a roadshow and the numbers have been picking up in the interest of the game.
“These events are critical in creating heroes and then supporting the sports themselves to build those grassroots games.”
New Zealand will hope for more heroes next year when the sporting world once again focuses on Japan and the 2020 Tokyo Olympics.
According to Kereyn Smith, chief executive of the New Zealand Olympic Committee, the team in Tokyo will have more athletes than ever before with over 200 expected to compete.
The total exceeded the previous best of 13 at the 1988 and 2012 games and marked the first occasion New Zealand women had won more medals at a Games than their male counterparts.
“I think that’s part of living in a culture of knowing who you are, you’re small, you’re at the bottom of the world, and you’re trying to always climb high mountains,” Smith said.
“It’s important to respect who you are, who you’re playing and where you’re going. I think that now we’ve become a little bit out from under the rock where we used to be, the underdog, trying to punch above our weight, now there’s a move in that psyche to say, ‘we can stand tall.'”
“Just because we’re a small country it doesn’t mean we can’t be competitive and take on and beat the best.”